First Stage: Learning and Understanding
I believe this is a phase that every Teapot enthusiast has gone through. All the Teapots look great (depending on personal preferences, some prefer square-shaped pots, some like Flower-adorned ones, some favor plain ones, and others like those with engravings). During this period, one tends to acquire teapots they like regardless of others' opinions. Due to individual economic differences, these pots can range from tens to thousands in price. Regardless of their cost, the best tea at home is used to honor them, sometimes even becoming an object of constant affection.
If a friend says they're not good, one might argue vehemently. If the friend is inexperienced or cannot provide convincing reasons, there will be no regrets about one's choices, and this phase may last longer, with a period of self-indulgence in admiration.
If the friend is knowledgeable, one will ponder their words after a debate. To prove who is right, one will read many relevant books and materials, and in doing so, the second stage begins!
Of course, some people will immediately look up related information after buying a pot because the names of the styles—like “ancient imitation,” “ball stack,” “stone ladle,” etc.—prompt a desire to know exactly what they've purchased. During this process, they come across online reviews of teapots, which marks the end of the first stage!
Second Stage: Deeper Understanding of purple Clay Teapots
This phase is confusing and even painful. This part of the journey is quite long and full of contradictions. After reading many books, looking up extensive information, and hearing countless comments about workmanship, clay, and styles, one realizes how limited and naive their previous understanding of teapots was.
With increased learning efforts, one becomes aware of terms like “surrogate work,” “mixed clay,” and “mold-made teapots.” At this point, contradictions arise, as the previously constructed ideal crumbles, ushering in a stage of mixed feelings! The resentment towards teapot sellers and unscrupulous artists (in a specific sense) clashes with an irresistible love for purple clay teapots!
During this time, choosing a trustworthy seller can shorten this contradictory process. One often encounters so-called experts who can mislead, yet these experts are likely at the same level as you. They might say the spout is good, the handle is nice, and the overall design is fine, but it's all rather vague. What makes it good? Do they understand the maker's intentions? It's doubtful they truly do!
Often, when a genuine expert points out flaws, one realizes their own naivety, leading to confusion among those seeking advice. This marks the beginning of conflict with these so-called experts, transitioning from admiration to doubt and even criticism!
Hence, the journey from novice to informed enthusiast is full of contradictions and pain (some may abandon their hobby, while more find their true purpose in teapot appreciation).
Third Stage: Developing Your Own Style of Teapot Appreciation
Reaching this stage deserves congratulations! You no longer listen to so-called experts; a good teapot is simply that—a good teapot, regardless of the maker's fame or title.
Your judgment and experience will no longer be swayed by others, even by makers themselves. Years of practice have taught you to appreciate the spirit and essence of a teapot, aspects that even some makers might miss. If they understood these elements, their craftsmanship wouldn't remain at its current level.
The pains and joys experienced during this journey are incomprehensible to the average enthusiast, and some might view your insights as misleading.